Share
We all know by now that change is constant in today’s business landscape, but how can organizations ensure their transformations truly succeed? Whether organizations are striving to integrate AI into their business models, undergoing digital transformation, or reshaping their organizational structures and leadership strategies, the need to evolve is undeniable. However, despite the increased focus and investment in these initiatives, many transformations fall short of their goals. The reason often lies in an overlooked but critical element: human behavior.
Having worked closely with numerous organizations during their transformation efforts, I’ve witnessed first-hand how they invest heavily in technology, strategy, and processes but often under-invest in the human side of change. The key to sustainable transformation isn’t just in the tools and strategies we implement—it’s in embedding behavioral change as a non-negotiable part of the journey. What truly drives this success is behavioral science, which provides the foundation for understanding and guiding the behavior modifications essential to making transformation stick.
The Challenge: Why Transformations Struggle
Despite significant investments in transformation initiatives, many organizations find it difficult to achieve their desired outcomes. The reasons for these challenges vary, but several critical factors can often hinder transformation efforts:
Unclear Target Results
One of the most critical factors in transformation is the clarity of the results organizations are aiming to achieve. Too often, transformation initiatives are launched with broad goals that lack the specificity needed to guide behaviors effectively. When the desired results are not clearly defined, it becomes difficult to pinpoint the exact behaviors required to achieve them. Which opens a new challenge: if you don’t know which behaviors you want to see to reach your results, you don’t know how to facilitate the necessary behavioral change. Without clear behavioral targets, it's nearly impossible to guide teams in adopting the right actions that lead to the desired outcomes.
Lack of Knowledge About Behavioral Change
Another significant barrier to successful transformation is the lack of understanding and application of behavioral science in change strategies. Many organizations focus heavily on the 'what' and 'how'—what tools to implement and how to restructure—but often overlook the underlying 'why' that drives human behavior. Behavioral science provides critical insights into how people respond to both antecedents (triggers) and consequences. Without this knowledge, leaders are unable to influence and sustain the behaviors necessary for successful transformation. The failure to understand and apply these principles leads to initiatives that may seem promising in the beginning but fail to create lasting change because they neglect the deeper behavioral dynamics at play.
Human Resistance
Even with the best strategies, tools, and processes in place, if people do not change their behaviors, transformation efforts will fail to gain traction. Human resistance remains one of the most significant obstacles during transformations and change initiatives. This resistance often manifests as hesitation, disengagement, subtle forms of manipulation, or open defiance to adopting new ways of working, all of which can hinder progress.
Recognizing that resistance is not simply a byproduct of change but a critical factor to address head-on is essential for leaders. Without proactively managing resistance, organizations risk stalling their transformation initiatives or, even worse, striving toward the wrong direction in their efforts to achieve better results. Addressing resistance requires a comprehensive approach that considers the triggers for change and the consequences of behavior, ensuring that the resistance is managed effectively to support the transformation goals.
Behavioral Science: A Crucial Leadership Skill for Guiding Change
At its core, behavioral science studies why we do what we do and how to change those behaviors effectively. When applied to business, it serves as a framework for understanding and guiding behaviors that can be pivotal in delivering results and achieving lasting improvements.
One essential principle of behavioral science is the clear definition of behavior. In transformation efforts, organizations often use broad and ambiguous terms like “transparency,” “collaboration,” or values like “trust” and “safety.” While I believe these words are used with good intentions to simplify things, they often result in the opposite. They can be valuable but also be interpreted in many different ways, making it difficult for individuals to know exactly how to act in alignment with them.
In behavioral science, the focus is on observable and measurable behaviors. This approach allows leaders to move beyond vague language and specify the concrete actions they want to see. For example, instead of promoting “collaboration”, it’s important to define what collaboration looks like in practice. Is it having regular cross-functional meetings? Sharing project updates proactively? When behaviors are clearly defined, it becomes easier to reinforce them, ensuring everyone in the organization understands what is expected.
Once behaviors are clearly defined, the focus shifts to reinforcement, a key element in shaping and sustaining change. In short, behaviors that are rewarded tend to be repeated, while behaviors that aren’t tend to fade away. However, reinforcement is not one-dimensional. Behavioral science recognizes multiple types of consequences that influence behavior. Without going into too much detail, understanding and applying these different types of reinforcement is essential for creating an environment where positive behaviors are sustained, and negative ones are minimized. By focusing on the appropriate use of these consequences, leaders can create an environment that motivates people to adopt new behaviors in alignment with organizational goals.
An important aspect of reinforcement is ensuring that the consequences are actually experienced by the person whose behavior you are trying to influence. It’s easy for leaders to assume that a consequence is effective because they see it, but if the performer of the behavior doesn't experience the consequence, it will have little impact. To truly encourage new behaviors, the consequence—whether positive or negative—needs to be meaningful to the person performing the behavior, not just the person overseeing the change.
The Role of Leadership
One of the key insights from behavioral science is that environment shapes behavior. This means that if you want people to adopt new behaviors, you need to design an environment that supports and reinforces those behaviors. Leadership plays a central role in shaping that environment for successful transformations. It extends beyond setting strategy or focusing on execution. The true impact of leadership lies in modeling the behaviors that are essential to achieve the desired results. In fact, one of the most effective ways to promote behavioral change is for leaders to demonstrate the new behaviors themselves. This means leaders must be willing to change their own behaviors first.
Leaders cannot expect their teams to adopt new ways of working if they aren’t willing to do the same. One of the most valuable steps a leader can take is to deepen their understanding of how behavioral change works. By gaining knowledge in this area, leaders not only show their commitment to the transformation but also set a powerful example.
Showing new behavior is a strong initial step, but reinforcing it is key. When leaders not only demonstrate the (new) desired behaviors but also reinforce those behaviors through positive consequences, it increases the likelihood that they will repeat them. This not only strengthens their own leadership but also serves as a valuable trigger for those they lead. When people see their leaders consistently embody and reinforce new behaviors, it can act as a catalyst for their own behavioral change.
By prioritizing their own development and modelling the right behaviors, leaders can inspire the broader organization to follow them, making behavioral change a natural part of the transformation journey.
The Key to Sustainable Success
For transformation efforts to succeed and be sustainable, behavioral change must be viewed as non-negotiable. It requires going beyond surface-level initiatives and embedding behavioral science into the foundation of the organization. Leaders must take ownership of this process, starting with their own behavior and extending to the teams they lead.
By adopting behavioral science principles, leaders gain the skills needed to guide and sustain change. This ensures that transformation efforts not only succeed in the short term but endure, setting the organization up for future challenges and continued growth.
At Xebia, we help leaders and organizations understand how to harness the power of behavioral science to drive sustainable transformation. By aligning strategy, technology, and human behavior, we empower our clients to navigate the complexities of change and achieve lasting success.